Joan Throckmorton has another day of extreme fits while Agnes Samuel prays heartily for her. When Agnes is asked whether Joan's fit is wantonness, as Mother Alice Samuel had often said, Agnes replies "now she could not deny, but that it was some supernaturall worke in the patient."(69-70)

During her fits, Joan claims to be visited by the spirit Catch, who tells her Pluck has broken his leg. She tries to break Catch's leg, but falls; he departs after numerous more attempts to do him injury.(69-70)