James Day claims he went to his uncle Patrick Dawson's house, where his Aunt Dawson sent a girl (Anonymous 357) to fetch Father Barwell. "Soon after a Person came in," who was an old woman (Anonymous 358) dressed in friar's clothing. She allegedly tells James Day she is risen from the dead, and that he should "change his Religion and turn to Mass."(2)

Mr. Travers, a minister, is informed by Roger Day of James Day's desire to turn papist. Mr. Travers investigates the events that caused this decision, and discovers that James Day was allegedly visited by an old woman (Anonymous 358), who claimed to be risen from the dead. Upon searching for the old woman, she was impossible to find, and further identified as "a begger Woman." Mr. Travers suspects James Day's story "had been designedly forg'd."(2)

Upon the discovery of the "popish cheat" developed by the Dawson and Tuit family through the confession of James Day, Patrick Dawson, his wife, James Tuit, and Joan Tuit are all "apprehended and bound over to the next Quarter Sessions" by Sir Humphrey Jervise. The old woman (Anonymous 358) and the priests (Anonymous 360 and Anonymous 361) are not discovered.(2)